So, I am taking a break from the music reviews for now. Which is good, because it is time for another Doctor Who review. This time for the second episode in Season 5, "The Beast Below." After raving about the third episode I must say this one does not have the same praise. This does not mean it is a horrible episode by any means, but it is lacking, or maybe over filled.
The beginning of the episode starts off promising enough. What with Amy being in space for the first time and landing on the future colony of England on a spaceship. All very science fictiony and what not. This is all well and good, until the plot decides to go off into what feels like a million directions, when it could have been simplified, and convey the same point but far more organized.
Soon after arriving on the ship, the Doctor and Amy split up. Eventually Amy is captured, put into a sort of voting both, and shown how the ship is moving without having any actual engines to propel it. She is given the option to forget what she sees or protest. She opts to forget, and is set free. At the same time the Doctor encounters Liz Ten, who later we find out is Queen Elizabeth the Tenth.
The story ends up revealing that the humans are torturing a Star Whale (yes, a Star Whale, a Whale in space) held captive under the ship to make it move. Eventually Amy realizes that the Star Whale came to help them, and if they do not torture it it shall move faster and be more productive.
Overall it is not a horrible premise, but within a 45 minute time slot there are many small nuances such as the Smiler's, who do nothing but add some rather useless parts to the overall progression of the story. Essentially, it seems as if the episode was made to be two parts, but was cramed into one. Though, it does make it clear that Amy is officially the new companion of the series, and makes some social commentaries about humans enslaving those they believe they can exploit. The final verdict for the episode is a 7 (or 6.5 still undecided)/10.
No comments:
Post a Comment